Much like my nearly unreadable schoolboy script has degraded over 25 years of typing on computers, so too have halt and record progress in a game diminished. The culprit is the advent of automatic saving, save points, Xbox Quick Resume, and games with such high stakes that I feel compelled to save constantly just in case disaster strikes. Yet, I am fallible. I get lazy. And this week, I was taught an important lesson eight hours into the newly ported Pokémon FireRed on Nintendo's console: you still gotta smash that save button.
Many years had gone by since I engaged with a classic Pokémon title — having missed the boat on the GBA era, the Generation II titles may have been the final core Pokémon game I completed. Therefore, I was excited to pony up $19.99 for the nostalgic return to the Kanto region, and a quest gathering those first 151 creatures. I immediately snapped back to a simpler time. Across several nights, I snagged Caterpie and Weedle, picked up an early Pikachu, defeated the first Gym Leader on my first turn, took a chance on purchasing the Magikarp from a shady character, and traversed Mt. Moon without a worry in the world.
The critical error: Not once did I save! The idea simply didn't occur to me.
That Jigglypuff shall never find love with my Mankey.
Everything went wrong during a session while I was taking a break from the game… and as my daughter picked up the Switch for a swift 30 minutes of the latest game instead, quitting my application as a result. As any Switch user understands (a fact I foolishly ignored…) opening a new game on the console will close the active game. Your progress is only safe when an autosave triggers or after a manual save before switching. My mistake.
The Evolution of Game Saves: From Intentional to Invisible
We should regard autosave, now so invisible its operation is largely unconscious, as a genuine “cutting-edge” advancement. Although the classic text game Zork featured among the first save functions in a game, 1986’s The Legend of Zelda is often credited as a landmark achievement for not feeling totally ruined by an in-game fail thanks to persistent memory saves in NES games. Naturally, the onus was still on you to save. (And once you erred), you’d never forget. Through the 1990s, save cards for systems like PlayStation popularized saving yet still fragile; neglecting to save (or misplacing a memory card) meant losing significant playtime. Games like Resident Evil even turned saving into a limited resource.
Today's automatic saving, which suppressed my manual save habit my retro gaming session so effectively, took hold around the turn of the millennium. The original Halo introduced checkpoint saving as the Call of Duty series honed the approach to streamline challenge and eliminate repetition. As the play grew longer — and more open-world — programmers mastered the technique of persistent, invisible saving and, eventually, the holy grail of instant on/off.
The Pokémon Series' Path: From Conscious Choice to Unconscious Backup
Funny enough, the world of Pokémon serves as a perfect mirror of how saving has changed. For years, saving in a Pokémon game required a manual command: players were trained to manually record their data ahead of powering down their Game Boy or DS. Starting with Pokémon Sword and Shield for the Nintendo Switch, the games added autosave (which players could turn off), signaling a significant design shift for a franchise known as most tradition-bound franchises.
I can admit failure: Years of playing Breath of the Wild and recent platformers totally eroded my manual save reflex. I am still wary with certain games — I won’t even gamble quitting during a run in a challenging indie title despite being aware it autosaves after chambers — but be it because my extended absence from older game design, or modern conveniences have softened me, I didn't even think to manually save before putting the console down. My younger self would never have fumbled to this degree.
The Consequences: Starting From Scratch
I have not picked up FireRed after my data loss incident. Upon rebooting the game and discovered my team consisted solely of my starter Squirtle, my motivation evaporated. Status condition: Burned.
Perhaps I'll restart… or perhaps I'll remain in the hundreds of new games released constantly that kindly assume I can’t remember to save. Still, my fondness for older titles isn’t dead. During times I can distract my kid to pause auto-saving Pokémon Legends: Z-A, we enjoy playing together a collection of classic Bomberman games. Those games from a bygone era had no save system at all relying purely on lengthy password codes. So, even if I make a fatal mistake, it’s not a total loss. That, at least, is reassuring.